When Moms Judge Moms

As a new mom, I was kind of like a sponge. Every bit of information regarding children would be soaked up. I believed everything, much to my chagrin now.

I dreamed of becoming a super mom and getting this parenting gig right.

Of course, my kids would grow to be angels, always hold my hand and never have ice cream for breakfast. I’d do everything right, have ever-lasting energy and put my feet up during the day while my children lovingly played on the floor.

Reality hit me, right in the middle of Piggly Wiggly aisle 6.

The tantrum of all tantrums and the floor being polished by my son as he rolled around flailing and shrieking. The glances from the other shoppers surely told me I was being judged.

I tried to reason with my son, bribed my son and finally, I mustered up enough strength to grab him, my purse and leave the store amidst gaping mouths and looks of disgust from other badge-wearing moms.

The grocery cart remained in aisle 6… along with my pride.

Son 1, Mom 0.

To add salt to my already gaping wound, another mother came over to the car and told me how I was doing it wrong. What I should be doing is this as she explained her parenting technique (which was raising the world’s most amazing kids). I was doing this mothering thing wrong. Obviously. I should have disciplined her way because my way wasn’t working.

I could have popped her in the nose. Did I just admit that?

Isn’t it funny that as soon as we see a positive sign on the little test strip, we enter the vicious world of mommy slamming? Right away we need to join collaborations with teams. Team cloth diapers vs. Team Pampers.

From there we move up to Team formula vs Team breastfeeding.

Do you ever feel like you are being judged for your parenting decisions? Here are 6 tips to remember in those times when moms judge moms.


Why Do Moms Judge Moms?

As we journey through the early days through adolescence and beyond, it seems like mommies are pitting themselves against each other.

What for? Does it really matter in the grand scheme of things?

Honestly, does it matter that I breastfed for over 2 years, I mean really? Does it hurt you or impact you?

These bullying sessions only leave us feeling shame, guilt and failure. We miss the greatest moments of our children’s lives because we are trying to be someone we are not.

As a result, we retreat from our mommy friends or other outspoken friends. We may even give in to the temptation to just give up and not really care about anything anymore.

Secrets of Motherhood

“God made each of us to parent differently. The methods we choose aren’t as important as the lessons we entrust.”

God chose us as a parent for each unique child, and He hand-picked each child for us. He wants us to turn confidently to Him for all parenting needs. He will give us wisdom when we ask.

What I need to remember when moms judge me:

  • Every mom doesn’t get it right all the time. The supermom has to take off her cape too.
  • Listening to other’s opinions makes us question what we’re doing. God tells us to ask Him for wisdom. Therefore, this should be our first place to get knowledge and insight about parenting.
  • God is leading you, the method you choose or the direction He leads will be different from other moms.
  • Every mom needs encouragement. Period.
  • God will deal with the injustices of judgment. As a result, leave it to Him to decide.
  • Trust God as you parent.


As Christian moms, I hope we overlook these shaming sessions and rather give grace to one another. We’re going to mess up and even when we teach and show our kids Jesus, they will still swear and call others idiots.

When we look back on our parenting journey from the empty nest, our biggest accomplishments will have been leading our kids to Jesus and raising them with unconditional love. The rest pales in comparison; therefore, we need to encourage, support and build each other up wherever we are in our parenting journey.

Proverbs 17:27-28

27 Those who are sure of themselves do not talk all the time. People who stay calm have real insight. 28 After all, even fools may be thought wise and intelligent if they stay quiet and keep their mouths shut.


Julie Loos is the mom of 5 kids and has been happily married to Greg for 17 years. She loves to read, eat chocolate, drink iced tea and spend time writing in the midst of messes.
You can find her at her blog, Unmasking the Mess, here.

Similar Posts


  1. Moms judging moms is no harsher than being judged in any other area of our lives. It happens.
    I’ve learned it’s how I deal with it that matters and that I simply don’t live my life for people – so I don’t/won’t carry that burden.
    If there’s something to be learned, I’ll learn it. Lifes too short.

    PS – When I see that situation in a grocery store I have greater empathy for the mother because as mothers we’ve all been there.

  2. I really resonated with this post! The judgement we feel as moms does seem to be intense (and I had to carry a toddler kicking and screaming out of Walgreens with a newborn in a carrier within a week of giving birth to #2!) I like to call these people the accusers. I just wrote a post about some accusers who were unhappy when Jesus healed a woman on the Sabbath. The response Jesus gives them is awesome! http://www.kathyericksonwrites.com/blog-2/surrounded-by-accusers Thanks for the encouragement to look to God and not to our accusers!

  3. Thank you for sharing your story Julie. I’m sure you were feeling quite shamed during this event that took place. Sounds like you handled it well. I have no doubt you are a wonderful mother. Your heart for God shines through in your writing. Thank again for stopping by the other day. It is always great to hear from you. Be well friend. Have a fantastic week and may God continue to bless you and your family in all your endeavors.. even on trips to the store;)

  4. Thank you for your encouraging words! I, too, am a mother of five and I am going through the most difficult trial in parenting right now.

  5. I remember being an eager 23-year-old mother of my first child. MY children would NEVER throw a tantrum in Walmart. My children would always obey. My children would….And then I had my child and realized that this parenting thing isn’t a cake walk. In fact, it’s incredibly hard. But you know, 12 years later, and being the Mom of three amazing children, I’m so thankful for the hard times. They’ve taught me how to grow up. They’ve changed me. I’m not who I used to be and it’s awesome! I still lose it sometimes, but overall, I’m a lot more patient and a lot more relaxed. Best of all: I don’t parent my children to impress anyone anymore.

  6. Julie, this was so, so good. Since you were willing to confess the urge to bop that mom in the parking lot, I’ll also confess: I have SUCH a hard time not judging other moms whose kids are acting out! But the Lord is working on my heart and convicting me. I have lot of room to grow in this area, but with the Holy Spirit’s help, I am growing! I love the advice you gave to provide encouragement instead of judgment and to follow God’s leading, not worldly advice, as we parent these little ones to the glory of God!

  7. I love this post, Julie. I’m not sure why we spend so much mental energy trying to convince other moms that our way is “best.” It’s only in hindsight, I think, that we have perspective — like you mentioned, in the grand scheme of things does it matter what kind of diapers we used? I remember well, a year or two after our boys had finished with Little League (at age 12), a good friend looked at me and said, “Why did we think that was so important?”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.